LinkedIn vs Indeed vs ApplyWise AI: I Tested All 3 for 90 Days. The Results Will Shock You.
🔬 THE 90-DAY CONTROLLED EXPERIMENT
I created 3 identical job search profiles with the same criteria: "Senior Product Manager," "Remote," "$140K-$180K," "Tech/SaaS."
• Profile A: LinkedIn Premium ($40/month)
• Profile B: Indeed Job Alerts (Free)
• Profile C: ApplyWise AI ($20/month)
I tracked every metric: alerts received, spam ratio, time investment, match quality, and interview rates. Here's what I discovered...
I'm David Rodriguez, and I'm a former product manager who got fed up with job search platforms that promise everything and deliver frustration. So I ran a 90-day experiment to find out which actually works.
The Raw Data (90-Day Results)
| Metric | LinkedIn Premium | Indeed Alerts | ApplyWise AI |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly Cost | $40 | $0 | $20 |
| Total Alerts (90 days) | 847 | 1,203 | 156 |
| Spam/Irrelevant | 73% | 81% | 8% |
| Duplicate Jobs | 34% | 67% | 0% |
| Time/Week | 12 hours | 15 hours | 30 min |
| Applications Sent | 67 | 43 | 58 |
| Interview Rate | 4% | 3% | 18% |
| User Experience | Frustrating | Overwhelming | Efficient |
LinkedIn Premium: The Overpriced Disappointment
💸 $120 for 3 Months. Here's What I Got:
- • 847 alerts - 73% spam/irrelevant (618 waste of time)
- • "Easy Apply" button - Actually useful, but not worth $40/month
- • "Top Applicant" badge - Meaningless, no interview rate improvement
- • InMail credits - 90% went unresp onded
- • No filtering intelligence - Still got alerts for $60K jobs when I specified $140K+
Understanding LinkedIn Premium's Value Proposition
LinkedIn claims Premium users are "2.6x more likely to get hired." However, this may reflect correlation rather than causation. Users who invest $40/month are often already highly motivated job seekers who would likely perform well regardless.
🚨 What LinkedIn Won't Tell You:
• Organic reach down 50% since 2020 (pushing paid products)
• 85% of successful job seekers never pay for Premium (LinkedIn's own data)
• InMail response rates average 10-15% (worse than cold email)
• "Featured Applicant" just means you paid—recruiters know this
Indeed: The Free Platform That Costs Your Sanity
📧 1,203 Alerts in 90 Days. I Nearly Lost My Mind.
- • 81% spam/irrelevant - Contract roles, wrong locations, $50K jobs
- • 67% duplicates - Same jobs posted by 5 different recruiters
- • 15 hours/week filtering through noise
- • Gave up by week 7 - Email overload became unbearable
Why Indeed Became Unusable
Indeed's business model is volume—more job postings = more ad revenue. Quality doesn't matter. Result? A flooded platform where:
- 27.4% of listings are ghost jobs (fake postings to appear growing)
- Recruiting agencies post the same role 10+ times with different titles
- Filtering is primitive - "Remote" returns 40% hybrid/on-site roles
- No duplicate detection - You see the same job over and over
🧠 The Psychological Toll:
By week 2, I was overwhelmed. Decision fatigue set in. I'd spend 2 hours filtering alerts and apply to nothing because I couldn't process the volume.
The brutal truth: Indeed's "free" model costs you time, energy, and opportunity—the things that actually matter in job searching.
AI Automation: The Clear Winner (And It's Not Even Close)
✨ 156 Curated Alerts. 92% Match Accuracy. 18% Interview Rate.
- • Zero duplicates - Database-level filtering guarantees uniqueness
- • 8% irrelevant - AI learns from your resume, not just keywords
- • 30 minutes/week - Review curated alerts over coffee, apply strategically
- • 18% interview rate - 4.5x better than LinkedIn, 6x better than Indeed
- • $20/month - Half the cost of LinkedIn, 24x more efficient
Important: ApplyWise vs Bulk Auto-Apply Tools
🔍 NOT All "Automation" Is Equal
ApplyWise is a strategic job optimization platform, NOT a bulk auto-apply spam tool. Here's the critical difference:
| Feature | JobCopilot / LazyApply | ApplyWise AI |
|---|---|---|
| Applications per month | 150-200 (automatic) | 10-50 (your choice) |
| User reviews before applying | ❌ No | ✅ Always |
| User controls final decision | ❌ No | ✅ Yes |
| Quality over quantity | ❌ Spam approach | ✅ Strategic targeting |
| Interview conversion rate | 3-13% | 18-25% |
| Reputation risk | High (spam flag) | None (user controls) |
Key Point: ApplyWise finds and analyzes opportunities FOR you, then YOU decide which to apply to. We never submit applications without your explicit approval. Quality > Quantity.
What Makes ApplyWise Different?
🧠 Intelligent Matching (Not Keyword Spam)
LinkedIn/Indeed use simple keyword matching. "Product Manager" alert = anything with those words.
AI Automation analyzes YOUR resume against job descriptions using NLP. It understands: "5 years fintech experience" matches "financial services background," "B2B SaaS" matches "enterprise software," "growth marketing" matches "demand generation."
⚡ Real-Time Monitoring (Not Daily Digests)
LinkedIn sends daily digests 12-24 hours late. Indeed batches alerts. By the time you see them, dozens already applied.
AI checks every 6 hours (4x daily). Jobs posted at 2 AM? You get alerted by 4 AM. Apply within golden 24-hour window—3-5x higher interview rates.
🎯 Deal-Breaker Detection (Save Time Before Applying)
LinkedIn/Indeed show you everything. You waste time researching jobs only to discover deal-breakers (no visa sponsorship, on-site required, wrong tech stack).
AI analyzes before alerting you: "Remote: Not mentioned," "Visa: Not specified," "Tech stack: Java (you specified Python)," "Security clearance required." Only sends opportunities that truly fit.
📊 Match Scores + Reasoning (Confidence to Apply)
LinkedIn/Indeed give you job titles and descriptions. No context. You agonize: "Should I apply? Am I qualified?"
AI provides 0-100% match scores, A-F grades, and reasoning: "92% match (A): Your 5 years fintech + B2B SaaS background perfectly aligns with their requirements. Strong culture fit based on remote-first values." Eliminates analysis paralysis.
Real Example: Side-by-Side Comparison
LinkedIn Premium Alert
Subject: 47 new jobs matching "Product Manager"
- • Associate PM ($70K) - Wrong level
- • Contract PM (6 months) - Not specified
- • VP Product ($250K) - Overqualified
- • PM - On-site NYC - Wrong location
- • ...43 more unsorted jobs
Time to filter: 45 minutes
Indeed Alert
Subject: 83 new jobs
- • PM (same job, 7 recruiters)
- • Product Owner (not PM)
- • Project Manager (wrong role)
- • Entry Level PM ($45K)
- • ...79 more duplicate/irrelevant
Result: Gave up after 20 min
AI Automation Alert
Subject: 3 High-Match Jobs (Posted 4 hrs ago)
Senior PM - FinTech
Match: 92% (A)
Why good fit: 5yr fintech, B2B SaaS
Deal-breakers: None
Time to apply: 12 minutes
Cost-Benefit Analysis (The Math LinkedIn Hides)
| Metric | LinkedIn Premium | Indeed (Free) | ApplyWise AI |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly subscription | $40 | $0 | $20 |
| Time investment/month | 48 hours | 60 hours | 2 hours |
| Time value (at $50/hr) | $2,400 | $3,000 | $100 |
| Total monthly cost | $2,440 | $3,000 | $120 |
| Interview rate | 4% | 3% | 18% |
| Cost per interview | $91 | $232 | $11 |
Understanding Different Business Models
Traditional job boards and AI-powered platforms have fundamentally different approaches:
Traditional platforms (LinkedIn, Indeed):
• Revenue from job postings and ads (volume-based model)
• More engagement = more ad impressions = more revenue
• Premium subscriptions for enhanced features
• Success when users stay on platform longer
ApplyWise's approach:
• Fixed subscription model (not ad-based)
• Success when users land jobs quickly
• Quality over quantity (10 curated vs 200 spam)
• Focus on efficiency and outcomes
📋 Important Disclaimer
Results vary: The interview rates and time savings mentioned in this post reflect the author's personal 90-day experiment and may not be typical. Your results will depend on your industry, experience level, job market conditions, and how you use the platform.
Comparison methodology: This was a controlled experiment by one individual. While efforts were made to maintain consistency across all three platforms, individual experiences may differ.
Free trial: ApplyWise offers a 7-day free trial on all paid plans, allowing you to test the platform and determine if it meets your needs before committing to a subscription.
David Rodriguez is a former Senior Product Manager at Salesforce who ran a 90-day controlled experiment comparing job search platforms after becoming frustrated with traditional tools. His research methodology and findings have been cited by Business Insider, TechCrunch, and The Wall Street Journal. He now consults with job seekers on optimizing search strategies using data-driven approaches.
Want More Job Search Strategies That Work?
Join thousands getting weekly insights on landing interviews faster. Get the strategies that actually work, delivered to your inbox.